Irvine Mold Lawsuits, Settlements & Damages
Legal Precedents & Case Outcomes
Irvine Company Mold Lawsuits, Settlements & Damages (Verified Sources)
Irvine Company Mold Lawsuits (Orange County & Newport Beach)
1) Nic Yavelak v. The Irvine Company — Hidden Mold at Antivo Los Olivos
Award: $423,000 jury verdict (affirmed on appeal)
Court: Orange County Superior Court (CA)
Complaint highlights: Hidden mold contamination behind walls; negligent remediation; failure to follow IICRC S520 standards; reliance on visual inspection only; habitability breach.
Outcome details: Jury found Irvine Company negligent and in breach of the implied warranty of habitability. The company appealed, and the judgment was reported as affirmed on appeal.
2) Duboc v. The Irvine Company, LLC — Water Intrusion & Toxic Mold (Newport Bluffs)
Status: Active/previously litigated; tentative ruling issued in 2020 (Case No. 30-2016-00894459).
Complaint highlights: Chronic water intrusion, hidden mold, misrepresentation of habitability; inadequate remediation.
Outcome details: Public record shows a tentative ruling (not a final judgment posted publicly). Indicates active litigation history.
3) Newport Bluffs Tenants Group Lawsuit — 17 Former Tenants (Filed Dec 2023)
Status: Ongoing litigation (no public verdict/settlement figure as of last update).
Complaint highlights: Toxic mold exposure; cognitive issues, rashes, respiratory illness; alleged knowledge of mold and cosmetic repairs only; non-disclosure of water intrusion history.
Related note: ABC7 reports Irvine Company previously sued a contractor over water intrusion and recovered $15M (construction-defect context).
Sources: The Real Deal report • ABC7 coverage • Alan Bell press brief
Note: Some Irvine Company matters are ongoing or have confidential elements. Where only a tentative ruling or complaint is public, dollar figures may not yet be available.
💰 High-Value Mold Verdicts (U.S. Landmark Cases)
Ballard v. Farmers Insurance (Texas)
Verdict: $32,000,000 (later reduced to ~$4,000,000 on appeal)
Complaint highlights: Failure to remediate water damage; widespread Stachybotrys mold; insurance bad faith.
Source: Sanair Environmental roundup
Florida Tenant Mold Case — Record Jury Award
Verdict: $48,257,922 (incl. ~$35M pain & suffering; ~$10M future medical)
Complaint highlights: Tenant lived ~18 months in mold-infested apartment; severe health impacts.
Source: Tyson & Mendes case write-up
Gorman / Construction-Lumber Mold Case (California)
Settlement: $22,600,000
Complaint highlights: Improperly stored lumber; indoor mold contamination; pediatric respiratory effects.
Source: Sanair Environmental roundup
Texas “Toxic Home” Construction Defect Verdict
Verdict: $3,100,000
Complaint highlights: Defective HVAC/insulation; chronic mold exposure; property rendered uninhabitable.
Source: Roofing Contractor article
Mid-Tier Settlements & Jury Awards
| Case | Amount | Summary | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
|
Las Palomas Apartments (Las Vegas, NV, 2025) |
$6,600,000 |
Ceiling collapse; chronic mold illness; landlord negligence. |
|
|
Whitestone Crossing (Cedar Park, TX, 2024) |
$1,060,000 |
Untreated leaks and mold; negligence proven at trial. |
|
|
Fort Cavazos Military Housing (2024) |
$10,300,000 |
Arbitration award for mold exposure in Army housing. |
|
|
McMahon Family v. Insurer (CA) |
$7,200,000 |
Insurance bad faith; extensive mold contamination. |
|
|
Heather Hill Apts (MD, 2025) |
$11,200,000 |
Global settlement for code violations incl. mold, pests. |
Key Legal Takeaways
- Negligence & Non-Disclosure: Highest awards tend to follow evidence of known leaks, hidden mold, and failure to remediate or disclose.
- Medical Documentation: Strong cases include physician documentation, exposure history, and environmental testing.
- Appeals & Reductions: Some verdicts are reduced or altered on appeal; many settlements remain confidential.
- Local Law Matters: Outcomes vary by state (habitability doctrines, statutes of limitations, damages caps).
Everyday Mold Lawsuits & Settlements
- Orange County, CA Family (2012): $350,000 settlement (residential mold). Conal Doyle Law
- Richmond, VA Tenant (2024): $588,000 jury award (toxic mold respiratory impacts). Halperin Law
- California Office Worker (LaFave Law): $2,850,000 workplace exposure. LaFave Law Group
- NYC 500-Unit Complex: $1,200,000 injury & repair settlement for widespread mold. Gelfand & Partners
FAQ
If you’re dealing with mold in your Irvine apartment or rental home, you may be wondering about your legal rights. Tenants in California are protected under state law, which requires landlords to maintain safe and habitable living conditions.
We update this page periodically with newly reported verdicts and settlements. Some active cases—especially those involving the Irvine Company—are still in litigation or under appeal.
Many cases settle before trial with confidentiality clauses. Where only a complaint or tentative ruling is public, a dollar figure may not exist yet.
No. This page is informational only. Speak with a licensed attorney about your specific situation.
Sources & References (Verify the Details)
- Yavelak v. Irvine Company: Strongin Law • News.Law • Appeal confirmation
- Duboc v. Irvine Company: Trellis Law
- Newport Bluffs Tenants lawsuit: The Real Deal • ABC7 • Alan Bell brief
- Florida ~$48.26M verdict: Tyson & Mendes
- Ballard v. Farmers (TX), Gorman $22.6M, McMahon $7.2M: Sanair Environmental roundup
- Texas “Toxic Home” $3.1M: Roofing Contractor
- Las Palomas $6.6M (NV): Multifamily Dive
- Whitestone Crossing $1.06M (TX): KUT.org
- Fort Cavazos $10.3M (military housing): Carlson Law Firm
- Heather Hill $11.2M (MD): Washington Post
- OC Family $350k (2012): Conal Doyle Law
- Richmond VA $588k: Halperin Law
- LaFave Law (various CA results): LaFave Law Group
- NYC 500-unit complex $1.2M: Gelfand & Partners
Disclaimer: This page is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Outcomes vary by facts and jurisdiction. Consult a licensed attorney for guidance.